History

5–7 October 2015

2015 Conference, Stockholm (Sweden)

The 8th Meeting of the Network of Prosecutors General or equivalent institutions at the Supreme Judicial Courts of the Member States of the European Union was held in Stockholm from 5 to 7 October 2015 under the auspices of the Swedish Prosecutor General.

The conference opened on 6 October 2015. The proceedings were structured around four main segments: an introductory session devoted to recent case law of the European Court of Human Rights in criminal matters; two thematic sessions focusing respectively on attacks against civil society and on the independence of the prosecution service; and a final session addressing the state of play of the project to establish the European Public Prosecutor’s Office. The meeting concluded with the adoption of formal conclusions.

The introductory session was delivered by Professor Iain Cameron (Uppsala University), who presented recent developments in the criminal case law of the European Court of Human Rights. His intervention highlighted the importance of States’ positive obligations, the need to reconcile effective prosecution with respect for fundamental rights, and the structuring role of the European Convention on Human Rights in European judicial cooperation.

The first thematic session, entitled “Attacks on civil society, challenging democracy and fundamental human rights,” featured substantial contributions from several Prosecutors General. Mr Jean-Claude Marin, Prosecutor General at the French Court of Cassation, developed an in-depth analysis of attacks on freedom of expression and freedom of religion in a context marked by recent terrorist attacks, stressing the necessity of maintaining a balance between security and fundamental freedoms. Mr Kai Lohse (Germany) examined how German criminal law addresses hate speech, Holocaust denial and terrorist propaganda, underlining the requirements of proportionality and legality. Mr Ole Hasselgaard (Norway) addressed the fight against hate crime as a component of the protection of fundamental rights, emphasising the obligation to conduct effective investigations and the need for a deterrent criminal response.

The conclusions adopted following this session underlined that attacks against civil society and fundamental freedoms constitute a direct threat to democracy. Members of the Network affirmed that prosecutors must both safeguard freedom of expression and act firmly against hate-motivated offences, while ensuring that the fight against such phenomena does not undermine the fundamental principles of the rule of law.

The second session was devoted to the independence of the prosecution service. Ms Lavly Perling, Prosecutor General of Estonia, and Mr Adriano Cunha (Portugal) presented national constitutional frameworks guaranteeing prosecutorial autonomy, distinguishing between external independence vis-à-vis the executive branch and internal autonomy in the handling of cases. The discussions highlighted the diversity of European models while identifying common principles: independence from undue influence, accountability, respect for the principle of legality and the need for adequate resources to ensure effective action. The session conclusions recalled that prosecutorial independence is an essential component of a fair criminal justice system and must be reconciled with appropriate mechanisms of democratic accountability.

The third session addressed the European Public Prosecutor’s Office and the state of negotiations. Ms Martine Solovieff, Prosecutor General of the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg, presented the progress made in discussions concerning the draft Regulation establishing the European Public Prosecutor’s Office, detailing the envisaged collegiate structure, the role of European Delegated Prosecutors and sensitive issues relating to material competence, judicial review and the relationship with Eurojust. Ms Michèle Coninsx, President of Eurojust, contributed reflections on the future relationship between Eurojust and the European Public Prosecutor’s Office, stressing the need for effective complementarity and a clear allocation of competences.

Members of the Network reaffirmed their continued interest in the establishment of the European Public Prosecutor’s Office, while emphasising that it must provide genuine added value in protecting the financial interests of the European Union, guarantee its independence and operate coherently alongside existing structures of judicial cooperation.

In the context of the Network’s internal matters, several decisions were adopted: the designation of the President of the Network as contact point with the European Judicial Training Network (EJTN) and the permanent inclusion on the agenda of an item concerning judicial training and cooperation with the EJTN; the appointment of Ms Claire Loftus, Director of Public Prosecutions of Ireland, as Vice-President of the Network; and the admission of the Prosecutors General of Serbia and Albania as observers.

The Stockholm conference in 2015 thus represented an important moment of collective reflection on the protection of civil society, the independence of the prosecution service and the evolving architecture of European criminal justice, confirming the Network’s role as a privileged forum for strategic dialogue among Prosecutors General of the supreme judicial courts of the European Union.