History
15–17 May 2019
2019 Conference, Tallinn (Estonia)
The 11th meeting of the Network of Prosecutors General at the Supreme Judicial Courts or equivalent institutions of the Member States of the European Union was held in Tallinn from 15 to 17 May 2019, at the invitation of Ms Lavly Perling, Prosecutor General of Estonia. The conference focused on the role of prosecution services in combating cybercrime and, more broadly, on the adaptation of judicial systems to digital transformation.
The first session, moderated by Mr Pavel Pukovec, Deputy Prosecutor General of the Czech Republic, was dedicated to the prosecutor’s role in the fight against cybercrime. It brought together Mr Max Hill, Director of Public Prosecutions for England and Wales, Mr Bogdan Święczkowski, National Prosecutor of Poland, Mr Darius Karcinskas, Deputy Prosecutor General of Lithuania, and Ms Petra Lundh, Prosecutor General of Sweden.
The discussions highlighted the profound evolution of the very concept of cybercrime. It became clear that the traditional distinction between “cyber-dependent” offences and conventional crimes is increasingly losing relevance, as the digital dimension now permeates virtually all areas of criminal law. Electronic evidence, online communications, cloud-stored data and digital transactions have become recurring elements in cases ranging from organised crime to domestic violence.
Speakers emphasised that prosecutors now operate within a highly complex technical environment. They must not only master the relevant legal framework but also understand the technical aspects of digital evidence, interact effectively with IT experts and present such evidence in a comprehensible manner before courts. The issue of specialisation within prosecution services was widely debated, with several participants advocating the development of dedicated expertise networks and training programmes, without isolating cybercrime as a wholly autonomous field.
A second session addressed the theme: Rule of law, data protection and the digital society. It explored the protection of fundamental rights in a context of increasing digitalisation. Ms Küllike Jürimäe, Judge at the Court of Justice of the European Union, analysed the delicate balance between public security requirements and the protection of privacy, particularly in light of European case law on the retention and access to electronic communications data.
Mr Riccardo Fuzio, Prosecutor General at the Italian Court of Cassation, placed these debates within a broader reflection on the threats and opportunities of the digital society, stressing the importance of preserving proportionality in investigative measures and ensuring respect for procedural guarantees.
The discussions confirmed that the fight against serious crime and terrorism requires effective digital tools, but that their use must remain strictly framed in order to safeguard the primacy of the rule of law.
Another session focused on the technical and organisational challenges posed by digital evidence and cross-border cooperation. Mr Drago Šketa, Prosecutor General of Slovenia, addressed the difficulties linked to encryption, remote data storage and the securing of electronic evidence.
Mr Klaus Meyer-Cabri, Vice-President of Eurojust, presented the “Digital Criminal Justice” initiative aimed at modernising the infrastructure for information exchange between national judicial authorities and European agencies. He underlined the need to develop secure, interoperable and efficient channels capable of responding to the almost systematic cross-border dimension of cases involving digital evidence.
The debates highlighted the importance of strengthened judicial cooperation adapted to technological realities, particularly in light of the uncertain localisation of data and the multiplicity of competent jurisdictions.
Finally, the conference addressed emerging forms of offences facilitated by digital technologies. Mr Jan Reckendorff, Director of Public Prosecutions of Denmark, presented cases involving the unlawful online distribution of intimate content concerning minors, illustrating the specific challenges posed by social networks and the rapid dissemination of content.
Mr Bogdan Święczkowski also stressed the need to train prosecutors as “cyberspace specialists”, capable of addressing both the technical and legal dimensions of offences committed online.
The Tallinn meeting confirmed that digital transformation represents a structural challenge for European prosecution services. It highlighted the need to adapt skills, internal organisation and international cooperation mechanisms, while maintaining a firm commitment to the fundamental principles governing the European area of justice.